School Refusal: Plenty of parents are experiencing the same morning drama
About 5% of children avoid school, either by complaining that they’re sick or simply refusing to go altogether, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics.
Of course, most kids don’t want to go to school every single morning. But, for some, the idea of walking into their classrooms is terrifying. Kids who refuse school can be worried about everything from failing an assignment and using a public bathroom to verbal taunts from other children, physical threats and actual injury, according to the AAP.
And while it may be tough to do, there’s really only one way to resolve the issue, said Phyllis Fagell, school counselor, therapist and author of “Middle School Matters:” You have to get them to school.
“School refusal is a form of anxiety, and all anxiety responds to exposure,” Fagell said. “The worst thing you can possibly do to a kid who refuses school is to keep them at home.”
When you allow your child to skip school because of anxiety, you’re essentially legitimizing their fears. You’re telling them that you also don’t think they can handle the stress of a school day and are reinforcing that there’s something to be afraid of once they get there.
“Whatever their fear is, you want to validate it because feelings are always valid and they won’t calm down and hear anything you say if they don’t feel validated,” Fagell said. “But then, they have to go to school.”
As any parent with a child who is experiencing school refusal can tell you, however, getting out the door, into the car and into the classroom isn’t easy. Fagell laid out four steps parents can take to get their kids in school before the bell rings.
For some kids, school refusal is a passing problem. Fagell worked with one third grade boy who didn’t want to go to school after two other boys rejected him at a birthday party. “I was able to tell him that, in this case, those two boys were the ones who were so concerned when he didn’t show up and they really wanted to see him,” she said. “That was a very easy one with a defined reason.”
For other students, school refusal is just another example of how anxiety is permeating their lives. In those cases, Fagell recommends finding a therapist who can help the child learn strategies to cope.
To get your child back into the classroom without a struggle, you’ll need support from school staff and a carefully crafted plan. “What we want to do is work up the exposure to get them fully walking into school on their own,” Fagell said.
It might begin with the child’s father walking them straight to their classroom after the bell rings. A few days later, the father would walk them to class before the bell rings. Then, maybe the father walks the child to the door where the guidance counselor meets them to take the child to their classroom.
“At some point, the child is walking on their own and doing it all on their own,” she said. “The idea is that those smaller exposures will desensitize them to the fear that’s keeping them out.”
For a successful entry back to school, you’ll need to get your child’s buy-in. “You want them to be a partner in the process,” Fagell said. “Most kids don’t want to be afraid of going to school forever. They want to work toward those goals.”
Once they do reach a goal—even a small one—celebrate it, she said. Positive feedback is important.
When kids are acting out because of anxiety, it’s important to remember that they aren’t refusing to go to school to irritate you or make you late for work.
“Go from thinking that this is intentional behavior intended to be provocative,” Fagell said, “to understanding that this is an involuntary subconscious response to the brain inaccurately perceiving threat.”
And, she said, to overcome it, they’ll need your support and compassion.